Well, no, but one can dream …
Note who is not listed here: the usual suspects of King, Poe, and Lovecraft. I mean, they’re just givens, even King with whom I have problems but cannot deny his earlier, better horror stories. Those listed below are besides them and mostly hark back to classic days, primarily because a writer needs a body of work to examine before you can say they’re the best of this or that category. A lot of the current crop of horror writers are purty good, but I don’t have enough of a sample to make a judgment, with exceptions. Also, I have a strict definition of horror – it must contain a supernatural or paranormal element. Otherwise, it’s a thriller. All serial killer books are thrillers, no matter how scary. So, then, in no particular order:
10. Ambrose Bierce: Better known for his mysterious disappearance in Mexico in 1913, Bierce was a journalist and savage critic who fought at Shiloh and wrote a ton of essays and short stories, most of which were considered ‘weird tales,’ in the parlance of the time. The Devil’s Dictionary is probably one of the best political satires, and you may have seen the Twilight Zone adaptation of An Occurrence at Owl’s Creek. I firmly believe his story, The Damned Thing, influenced Lovecraft’s The Colour out of Space.
9. August Derleth- well known as a publisher and anthologist who helped establish Arkham House as a vehicle for Lovecraft’s work, he was also no slouch as a writer. His Sac Prairie Saga earned him a Guggenheim fellowship sponsored by Helen White, Sinclair Lewis, and Edgar Lee Masters. He used the prize to bind his comic book collection. Maxwell Perkins, famous for developing Thomas Wolfe’s work, was Derleth’s literary agent. Derleth came up with the term ‘Cthulhu mythos’ to encompass Lovecraft’s writings and took over the mythos after Lovecraft’s death in 1937, writing somewhat more hopeful stories. The King in Yellow wasn’t necessarily going to eat you. Derleth and Arkham House pretty much rescued the horror genre, giving writers like Ramsey Campbell encouragement. Derleth published Ray Bradbury’s first novel, Dark Carnival.
8. Algernon Blackwood- born in London to quasi-royalty, Blackwood worked as a dairy farmer in Canada, a bartender and model in New York City, and a violin teacher. Pretty varied career. He moved back to London around 1910 or so and began writing ghost stories, The Wendigo probably the best known. He wrote 14 novels, a couple of juvenile novels, several plays, and uncounted stories because he often wrote for local newspapers at short notice and with no credit. Tolkien said his term “the crack of doom” came from a Blackwood story, probably Blackwood’s 1909 novel, The Education of Uncle Paul.
7. Ray Bradbury- of course Bradbury’s going to be here because he remains my favorite writer of all time and the one who has influenced my own writing the most. Sure, yeah, The Martian Chronicles, R is for Rocket, all that science fiction, but he also wrote excellent horror, including the aforementioned Dark Carnival, The October Country, and my favorite, Something Wicked This Way Comes, which was turned into a somewhat decent movie with Jason Robards.
6. Henry Kuttner. Quite the prolific writer, but, for our purposes, most famous for The Book of Iod, which contains several of his Cthulhu mythos stories. Kuttner was part of Lovecraft’s inner circle, where he met his wife, C L Moore, who was one of the first women science fiction writers. The two of them wrote several books and stories together under the name Lewis Padgett, including The Mimsy Was the Borogroves, which is the basis for the movie The Last Mimsy.
5. Robert Bloch- you’d expect either Bloch or Richard Matheson about now, but I give the lead to Bloch, who most of you know wrote Psycho. He wrote everything, it seems, including a lot of Cthulhu mythos stories that so impressed Lovecraft he dedicated his story, The Haunter of the Dark, to Bloch. One of my favorites of his, Your’s Truly, Jack the Ripper, is an excellent supernatural treatment of a serial killer story.
4. Theodore Sturgeon- like Block and Matheson, this guy wrote everything, including one of the best vampire stories, Some of Your Blood, which may not actually be a vampire story. You decide. A good friend of Kurt Vonnegut – Kilgore Trout is based on him- he also did a couple of Star Trek episodes, introducing the Vulcan salute and “Live Long and Prosper.”
3. Elizabeth Massie – prolific writer who has won two Bram Stoker awards and who shares my conviction that making a story gross does not make it horror. If it induces nausea instead of terror, then it’s just disgusting and what’s that? I’ve been disgusted a lot without being scared. She is currently putting together a series of novels, called the Ameri-scares, that presents the best ghost stories per state. And she lives nearby.
2. M. R. James- probably the most influential horror writer of all, who inspired Lovecraft and Ruth Rendell and Paul Theroux, and completely restructured the old-fashioned ghost story, turning them into something far more contemporary … if you can call 1904 contemporary. He was a provost of King’s College and a medievalist who uncovered the graves of several 12th Century abbots. Walked the walk.
1. Margaret St. Clair. While you could actually consider her a scifi/thriller writer because of her post-apocalyptic novels such as The Dolphins of Altair, most of them rely on witchcraft for the events, so they count. She was a Wiccan priestess who occasionally visited nudist colonies with her husband, a Wiccan priest. Her best known story is The Boy Who Predicted Earthquakes, which is scifi with paranormal elements, so it counts. She wrote under the pseudonym Idris Seabright, and once appeared in an issue of Anthony Boucher’s The Magazine of Science Fiction and Fantasy under that name, had another story in the same issue under her real name alongside a story by her husband, Eric St. Clair. Boucher said that Eric is “married to two of my favorite writers.”